PocketEdge
← All news

Desk note · industry · Insurance / regulation

Insurers asked Irdai for expense rules that scale with company size

Insurers told the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India in feedback submitted by the 1 November 2026 deadline that uniform caps on expenses of management would hurt newer and smaller players, urging a tiered framework similar to recent scale-based rules for mutual funds and non-bank finance companies.

1 Nov 2026 · 2 min read

Key takeaways

  • •Irdai’s 23 September 2026 consultation paper proposed tighter limits on insurers’ expenses of management and distribution commissions; Saturday 1 November was the last day for industry comments.
  • •Executives argued smaller and newer insurers carry similar fixed costs on a smaller premium base, so a single EoM ceiling would force them to cut growth spending or fall behind larger rivals with scale efficiencies.
  • •Industry participants pointed to the Reserve Bank of India’s 2022 scale-based NBFC framework and Sebi’s upcoming mutual-fund scale rules as templates, while saying commission schedules themselves should stay uniform.

What's going on here?

Reporting on 1 November 2026 said life and general insurers filed responses to Irdai’s September consultation paper on distribution commissions and expenses of management. The regulator’s draft pushes insurers to trim operating costs measured as a share of premiums and to tighten what they pay agents, banks, and other distributors. Industry executives told reporters that applying one expense ceiling to every insurer ignores how fixed setup costs spread differently once premium income scales. Smaller and newer entrants often report higher EoM ratios while they build branches, technology, and product shelves, even when their absolute spending is lower than large incumbents. Icra analysts quoted in the same coverage said differentiated supervision could prevent mid-sized players from deferring growth investments just to meet a uniform ratio on a short timeline.

What does this mean?

Insurance penetration in India still depends on agents and bancassurance partners reaching towns where paperwork and service costs do not shrink just because a company is young. If regulators cap expenses uniformly, the math can push smaller insurers to shrink marketing, slow branch additions, or chase only large-ticket business that clears the ratio test. Scale-based rules would instead tie compliance intensity to premium volume, asset size, or systemic importance, much as the RBI already does for NBFC layers and Sebi will do for mutual funds from April 2026. Commissions themselves would remain on the regulator’s schedule, so the fight is about headroom for non-commission operating spend, not about paying agents more. Irdai chief Ajay Seth has publicly said he wants more good-sized insurers rather than a market of three or four giants, which makes the industry’s tiered proposal a direct test of that goal.

Why should I care?

If you buy life or health cover through a bank or agent, watch whether smaller insurers pull back on service touchpoints or slow new product launches if uniform caps bite before a tiered compromise emerges. Corporate HR teams negotiating group policies should compare claim service levels, not just premium quotes, when challengers face tighter economics. Investors in listed insurers should model how proposed EoM paths interact with growth plans at mid-cap names versus scale leaders. Follow Irdai’s final circular, any phased transition dates, and whether risk-based capital rules arriving with Ind-AS 117 from FY28 offset the expense squeeze. Commission tables for 2026-27 will still set what your agent earns; the open question is how much insurers can spend to reach you.

More desk notes

Disclaimer

For informational purposes only. Not investment advice. Verify with filings and a licensed adviser.